Vulnerability introduced to AppVMs via Template dependency partially mitigated

THREATQW58 · Partially mitigated: Some controls are in place, but the risk is still too high. · Defined in catalog.py:3827

Risk: High impact × Low likelihood = 6 medium
After mitigations: High impact × Low likelihood = 6 medium (unchanged)

How statuses and scores work

An upstream package installed in the AppVM template introduces a vulnerability or backdoor into the TemplateVM and AppVMs on which it is based

Threat actors: Any

Mitigations

Mitigation	Status
grsecurity in all Debian templates MITIGQW3	implemented
create individual templates for each role in workstation to minimize unnecessary package installs MITIGQW24	implemented

Where it applies

Applies to 9 components in 3 scenarios.

sd-app (SecureDrop Client) Workstation VMs
sd-devices (export and print) Workstation VMs
sd-gpg Workstation VMs
sd-log Workstation VMs
sd-proxy Workstation VMs
sd-viewer (disposable VMs) Workstation VMs
sys-firewall Workstation VMs
sys-net Workstation VMs
sys-usb Workstation VMs

Workstation: reading submissions · sd-app (SecureDrop Client), sd-proxy, sys-firewall, sys-net, sd-gpg, sd-viewer (disposable VMs), sd-log

digraph tm {
    graph [
        fontname = Arial;
        fontsize = 14;
    ]
    node [
        fontname = Arial;
        fontsize = 14;
    ]
    edge [
        fontname = Arial;
        fontsize = 12;
    ]
    nodesep = 1;

    subgraph cluster_boundary_Application_Server {
        graph [
            fontsize = 10;
            fontcolor = black;
            style = dashed;
            color = firebrick2;
            label = <<i>Application Server</i>>;
        ]

        component_Journalist_Interface_Application_Server [
            shape = circle;
            color = black;
            fontcolor = black;
            label = "Journalist\nInterface";
            URL = "component_Journalist_Interface.html";
            tooltip = "Journalist Interface";
            margin = 0.02;
        ]

    }

    subgraph cluster_boundary_SecureDrop_Workstation {
        graph [
            fontsize = 10;
            fontcolor = black;
            style = dashed;
            color = firebrick2;
            label = <<i>SecureDrop Workstation</i>>;
        ]

        subgraph cluster_boundary_Workstation_VMs {
            graph [
                fontsize = 10;
                fontcolor = black;
                style = dashed;
                color = firebrick2;
                label = <<i>Workstation VMs</i>>;
            ]

            component_sd_app__SecureDrop_Client__Workstation_VMs [
                shape = circle;
                color = black;
                fontcolor = black;
                label = "sd-app\n(SecureDrop\nClient)";
                URL = "component_sd_app__SecureDrop_Client_.html";
                tooltip = "sd-app (SecureDrop Client)";
                margin = 0.02;

                style = "filled";

                fillcolor = "#c0392b";

                fontcolor = "white";

                class = "highlighted";
            ]

            component_sd_gpg_Workstation_VMs [
                shape = circle;
                color = black;
                fontcolor = black;
                label = "sd-gpg";
                URL = "component_sd_gpg.html";
                tooltip = "sd-gpg";
                margin = 0.02;

                style = "filled";

                fillcolor = "#c0392b";

                fontcolor = "white";

                class = "highlighted";
            ]

            component_sd_log_Workstation_VMs [
                shape = circle;
                color = black;
                fontcolor = black;
                label = "sd-log";
                URL = "component_sd_log.html";
                tooltip = "sd-log";
                margin = 0.02;

                style = "filled";

                fillcolor = "#c0392b";

                fontcolor = "white";

                class = "highlighted";
            ]

            component_sd_proxy_Workstation_VMs [
                shape = circle;
                color = black;
                fontcolor = black;
                label = "sd-proxy";
                URL = "component_sd_proxy.html";
                tooltip = "sd-proxy";
                margin = 0.02;

                style = "filled";

                fillcolor = "#c0392b";

                fontcolor = "white";

                class = "highlighted";
            ]

            component_sd_viewer__disposable_VMs__Workstation_VMs [
                shape = circle;
                color = black;
                fontcolor = black;
                label = "sd-viewer\n(disposable VMs)";
                URL = "component_sd_viewer__disposable_VMs_.html";
                tooltip = "sd-viewer (disposable VMs)";
                margin = 0.02;

                style = "filled";

                fillcolor = "#c0392b";

                fontcolor = "white";

                class = "highlighted";
            ]

            component_sys_firewall_Workstation_VMs [
                shape = circle;
                color = black;
                fontcolor = black;
                label = "sys-firewall";
                URL = "component_sys_firewall.html";
                tooltip = "sys-firewall";
                margin = 0.02;

                style = "filled";

                fillcolor = "#c0392b";

                fontcolor = "white";

                class = "highlighted";
            ]

            component_sys_net_Workstation_VMs [
                shape = circle;
                color = black;
                fontcolor = black;
                label = "sys-net";
                URL = "component_sys_net.html";
                tooltip = "sys-net";
                margin = 0.02;

                style = "filled";

                fillcolor = "#c0392b";

                fontcolor = "white";

                class = "highlighted";
            ]

        }

    }

    actor_Journalist_ [
        shape = square;
        color = black;
        fontcolor = black;
        label = "Journalist";
        URL = "component_Journalist.html";
        tooltip = "Journalist";
        margin = 0.02;
    ]

    actor_Journalist_ -> component_sd_app__SecureDrop_Client__Workstation_VMs [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "1. Use the client";    ]
    component_sd_app__SecureDrop_Client__Workstation_VMs -> component_sd_proxy_Workstation_VMs [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "2. Journalist API\nrequest";    ]
    component_sd_proxy_Workstation_VMs -> component_sys_firewall_Workstation_VMs [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "3. Route via\nfirewall";    ]
    component_sys_firewall_Workstation_VMs -> component_sys_net_Workstation_VMs [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "4. Route to network";    ]
    component_sys_net_Workstation_VMs -> component_Journalist_Interface_Application_Server [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "5. Reach the\nJournalist Interface";    ]
    component_Journalist_Interface_Application_Server -> component_sys_net_Workstation_VMs [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "6. Encrypted\nsubmissions";    ]
    component_sd_proxy_Workstation_VMs -> component_sd_app__SecureDrop_Client__Workstation_VMs [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "7. Relay to client";    ]
    component_sd_app__SecureDrop_Client__Workstation_VMs -> component_sd_gpg_Workstation_VMs [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "8. Decrypt";    ]
    component_sd_app__SecureDrop_Client__Workstation_VMs -> component_sd_viewer__disposable_VMs__Workstation_VMs [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "9. Open a file";    ]
    component_sd_app__SecureDrop_Client__Workstation_VMs -> component_sd_log_Workstation_VMs [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "10. Send logs";    ]
}

Workstation: export and print · sd-app (SecureDrop Client), sd-devices (export and print), sys-usb, sd-viewer (disposable VMs), sd-log

digraph tm {
    graph [
        fontname = Arial;
        fontsize = 14;
    ]
    node [
        fontname = Arial;
        fontsize = 14;
    ]
    edge [
        fontname = Arial;
        fontsize = 12;
    ]
    nodesep = 1;

    subgraph cluster_boundary_SecureDrop_Workstation {
        graph [
            fontsize = 10;
            fontcolor = black;
            style = dashed;
            color = firebrick2;
            label = <<i>SecureDrop Workstation</i>>;
        ]

        subgraph cluster_boundary_Workstation_VMs {
            graph [
                fontsize = 10;
                fontcolor = black;
                style = dashed;
                color = firebrick2;
                label = <<i>Workstation VMs</i>>;
            ]

            component_sd_app__SecureDrop_Client__Workstation_VMs [
                shape = circle;
                color = black;
                fontcolor = black;
                label = "sd-app\n(SecureDrop\nClient)";
                URL = "component_sd_app__SecureDrop_Client_.html";
                tooltip = "sd-app (SecureDrop Client)";
                margin = 0.02;

                style = "filled";

                fillcolor = "#c0392b";

                fontcolor = "white";

                class = "highlighted";
            ]

            component_sd_devices__export_and_print__Workstation_VMs [
                shape = circle;
                color = black;
                fontcolor = black;
                label = "sd-devices\n(export and\nprint)";
                URL = "component_sd_devices__export_and_print_.html";
                tooltip = "sd-devices (export and print)";
                margin = 0.02;

                style = "filled";

                fillcolor = "#c0392b";

                fontcolor = "white";

                class = "highlighted";
            ]

            component_sd_log_Workstation_VMs [
                shape = circle;
                color = black;
                fontcolor = black;
                label = "sd-log";
                URL = "component_sd_log.html";
                tooltip = "sd-log";
                margin = 0.02;

                style = "filled";

                fillcolor = "#c0392b";

                fontcolor = "white";

                class = "highlighted";
            ]

            component_sd_viewer__disposable_VMs__Workstation_VMs [
                shape = circle;
                color = black;
                fontcolor = black;
                label = "sd-viewer\n(disposable VMs)";
                URL = "component_sd_viewer__disposable_VMs_.html";
                tooltip = "sd-viewer (disposable VMs)";
                margin = 0.02;

                style = "filled";

                fillcolor = "#c0392b";

                fontcolor = "white";

                class = "highlighted";
            ]

            component_sys_usb_Workstation_VMs [
                shape = circle;
                color = black;
                fontcolor = black;
                label = "sys-usb";
                URL = "component_sys_usb.html";
                tooltip = "sys-usb";
                margin = 0.02;

                style = "filled";

                fillcolor = "#c0392b";

                fontcolor = "white";

                class = "highlighted";
            ]

        }

    }

    component_Export_Device_ [
        shape = circle;
        color = black;
        fontcolor = black;
        label = "Export Device";
        URL = "component_Export_Device.html";
        tooltip = "Export Device";
        margin = 0.02;
    ]

    actor_Journalist_ [
        shape = square;
        color = black;
        fontcolor = black;
        label = "Journalist";
        URL = "component_Journalist.html";
        tooltip = "Journalist";
        margin = 0.02;
    ]

    actor_Journalist_ -> component_sd_app__SecureDrop_Client__Workstation_VMs [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "1. Choose export";    ]
    component_sd_app__SecureDrop_Client__Workstation_VMs -> component_sd_devices__export_and_print__Workstation_VMs [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "2. Hand file to\nexport VM";    ]
    component_sys_usb_Workstation_VMs -> component_sd_devices__export_and_print__Workstation_VMs [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "3. Attach USB device";    ]
    component_sd_devices__export_and_print__Workstation_VMs -> component_Export_Device_ [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "4. Write to drive";    ]
    component_sd_devices__export_and_print__Workstation_VMs -> component_sd_viewer__disposable_VMs__Workstation_VMs [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "5. Preview in\ndisposable VM";    ]
    component_sd_devices__export_and_print__Workstation_VMs -> component_sd_log_Workstation_VMs [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "6. Send logs";    ]
}

Workstation: boot, provisioning and updates · sd-gpg

digraph tm {
    graph [
        fontname = Arial;
        fontsize = 14;
    ]
    node [
        fontname = Arial;
        fontsize = 14;
    ]
    edge [
        fontname = Arial;
        fontsize = 12;
    ]
    nodesep = 1;

    subgraph cluster_boundary_External_Services {
        graph [
            fontsize = 10;
            fontcolor = black;
            style = dashed;
            color = firebrick2;
            label = <<i>External Services</i>>;
        ]

        component_FPF_apt_repository_External_Services [
            shape = circle;
            color = black;
            fontcolor = black;
            label = "FPF apt\nrepository";
            URL = "component_FPF_apt_repository.html";
            tooltip = "FPF apt repository";
            margin = 0.02;
        ]

    }

    subgraph cluster_boundary_SecureDrop_Workstation {
        graph [
            fontsize = 10;
            fontcolor = black;
            style = dashed;
            color = firebrick2;
            label = <<i>SecureDrop Workstation</i>>;
        ]

        subgraph cluster_boundary_Workstation_VMs {
            graph [
                fontsize = 10;
                fontcolor = black;
                style = dashed;
                color = firebrick2;
                label = <<i>Workstation VMs</i>>;
            ]

            component_sd_gpg_Workstation_VMs [
                shape = circle;
                color = black;
                fontcolor = black;
                label = "sd-gpg";
                URL = "component_sd_gpg.html";
                tooltip = "sd-gpg";
                margin = 0.02;

                style = "filled";

                fillcolor = "#c0392b";

                fontcolor = "white";

                class = "highlighted";
            ]

        }

        component_Qubes_OS_and_Xen_SecureDrop_Workstation [
            shape = circle;
            color = black;
            fontcolor = black;
            label = "Qubes OS and Xen";
            URL = "component_Qubes_OS_and_Xen.html";
            tooltip = "Qubes OS and Xen";
            margin = 0.02;
        ]

        component_Workstation_bootloader_SecureDrop_Workstation [
            shape = circle;
            color = black;
            fontcolor = black;
            label = "Workstation\nbootloader";
            URL = "component_Workstation_bootloader.html";
            tooltip = "Workstation bootloader";
            margin = 0.02;
        ]

        component_Workstation_firmware_SecureDrop_Workstation [
            shape = circle;
            color = black;
            fontcolor = black;
            label = "Workstation\nfirmware";
            URL = "component_Workstation_firmware.html";
            tooltip = "Workstation firmware";
            margin = 0.02;
        ]

        component_Workstation_hardware_SecureDrop_Workstation [
            shape = circle;
            color = black;
            fontcolor = black;
            label = "Workstation\nhardware";
            URL = "component_Workstation_hardware.html";
            tooltip = "Workstation hardware";
            margin = 0.02;
        ]

        component_Workstation_provisioning_code_SecureDrop_Workstation [
            shape = circle;
            color = black;
            fontcolor = black;
            label = "Workstation\nprovisioning\ncode";
            URL = "component_Workstation_provisioning_code.html";
            tooltip = "Workstation provisioning code";
            margin = 0.02;
        ]

        component_dom0_SecureDrop_Workstation [
            shape = circle;
            color = black;
            fontcolor = black;
            label = "dom0";
            URL = "component_dom0.html";
            tooltip = "dom0";
            margin = 0.02;
        ]

    }

    actor_Administrator_ [
        shape = square;
        color = black;
        fontcolor = black;
        label = "Administrator";
        URL = "component_Administrator.html";
        tooltip = "Administrator";
        margin = 0.02;
    ]

    actor_Journalist_ [
        shape = square;
        color = black;
        fontcolor = black;
        label = "Journalist";
        URL = "component_Journalist.html";
        tooltip = "Journalist";
        margin = 0.02;
    ]

    actor_Journalist_ -> component_Workstation_hardware_SecureDrop_Workstation [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "1. Power on";    ]
    component_Workstation_hardware_SecureDrop_Workstation -> component_Workstation_firmware_SecureDrop_Workstation [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "2. Start firmware";    ]
    component_Workstation_firmware_SecureDrop_Workstation -> component_Workstation_bootloader_SecureDrop_Workstation [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "3. Load bootloader";    ]
    component_Workstation_bootloader_SecureDrop_Workstation -> component_Qubes_OS_and_Xen_SecureDrop_Workstation [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "4. Boot Qubes";    ]
    component_Qubes_OS_and_Xen_SecureDrop_Workstation -> component_dom0_SecureDrop_Workstation [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "5. Start dom0";    ]
    actor_Administrator_ -> component_Workstation_provisioning_code_SecureDrop_Workstation [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "6. Install and\nconfigure";    ]
    component_Workstation_provisioning_code_SecureDrop_Workstation -> component_dom0_SecureDrop_Workstation [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "7. Apply salt states";    ]
    component_dom0_SecureDrop_Workstation -> component_sd_gpg_Workstation_VMs [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "8. Provide secret\nkeys";    ]
    component_dom0_SecureDrop_Workstation -> component_FPF_apt_repository_External_Services [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "9. Fetch updates";    ]
    component_FPF_apt_repository_External_Services -> component_dom0_SecureDrop_Workstation [        color = black;        fontcolor = black;        dir = forward;        label = "10. Signed packages";    ]
}

Notes

In scope for audit: No. Existing mitigations: grsecurity kernel (MITIGQW3), two distinct templates (MITIGQW24).

How this threat is matched

Listed for these components. A boundary covers every component inside it.